Intentionality an essay in the philosophy of mind 1983

Max Gerber] I am often asked whether I agree with the new group selectionists, and the questioners are always surprised when I say I do not.

Intentionality an essay in the philosophy of mind 1983

History of the issue Questions about the nature of conscious awareness have likely been asked for as long as there have been humans.

Intentionality an essay in the philosophy of mind 1983

Neolithic burial practices appear to express spiritual beliefs and provide early evidence for at least minimally reflective thought about the nature of human consciousness PearsonClark and Riel-Salvatore Preliterate cultures have similarly been found invariably to embrace some form of spiritual or at least animist view that indicates a degree of reflection about the nature of conscious awareness.

Nonetheless, some have argued that consciousness as we know it today is a relatively recent historical development that arose sometime after the Homeric era Jaynes According to this view, earlier humans including those who fought the Trojan War did not experience themselves as unified internal subjects of their thoughts and actions, at least not in the ways we do today.

Minds, Animal | Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Though the ancients had much to say about mental matters, it is less clear whether they had any specific concepts or concerns for what we now think of as consciousness. The Hamlet who walked the stage in already saw his world and self with profoundly modern eyes.


By the beginning of the early modern era in the seventeenth century, consciousness had come full center in thinking about the mind. Indeed from the midth through the late 19th century, consciousness was widely regarded as essential or definitive of the mental.

Later, toward the end of the 17th century, John Locke offered a similar if slightly more qualified claim in An Essay on Human UnderstandingI do not say there is no soul in man because he is not sensible of it in his sleep.

But I do say he can not think at any time, waking or sleeping, without being sensible of it.

What is Phenomenology?

Our being sensible of it is not necessary to anything but our thoughts, and to them it is and to them it always will be necessary. Locke explicitly forswore making any hypothesis about the substantial basis of consciousness and its relation to matter, but he clearly regarded it as essential to thought as well as to personal identity.

Leibniz was the first to distinguish explicitly between perception and apperception, i. In the Monadology he also offered his famous analogy of the mill to express his belief that consciousness could not arise from mere matter.

Consciousness (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)

He asked his reader to imagine someone walking through an expanded brain as one would walk through a mill and observing all its mechanical operations, which for Leibniz exhausted its physical nature.

Nowhere, he asserts, would such an observer see any conscious thoughts. Despite Leibniz's recognition of the possibility of unconscious thought, for most of the next two centuries the domains of thought and consciousness were regarded as more or less the same.

Associationist psychology, whether pursued by Locke or later in the eighteenth century by David Hume or in the nineteenth by James Millaimed to discover the principles by which conscious thoughts or ideas interacted or affected each other.

James Mill's son, John Stuart Mill continued his father's work on associationist psychology, but he allowed that combinations of ideas might produce resultants that went beyond their constituent mental parts, thus providing an early model of mental emergence The purely associationist approach was critiqued in the late eighteenth century by Immanuel Kantwho argued that an adequate account of experience and phenomenal consciousness required a far richer structure of mental and intentional organization.

Intentionality an essay in the philosophy of mind 1983

Phenomenal consciousness according to Kant could not be a mere succession of associated ideas, but at a minimum had to be the experience of a conscious self situated in an objective world structured with respect to space, time and causality.

Within the Anglo-American world, associationist approaches continued to be influential in both philosophy and psychology well into the twentieth century, while in the German and European sphere there was a greater interest in the larger structure of experience that lead in part to the study of phenomenology through the work of Edmund Husserl, Martin HeideggerMaurice Merleau-Ponty and others who expanded the study of consciousness into the realm of the social, the bodily and the interpersonal.Philosophy of mind is a branch of philosophy that studies the nature of the mind–body problem is a paradigm issue in philosophy of mind, although other issues are addressed, such as the hard problem of consciousness, and the nature of particular mental states.

Aspects of the mind that are studied include mental events, mental functions, mental properties, consciousness, the ontology. New Criticism. A literary movement that started in the late s and s and originated in reaction to traditional criticism that new critics saw as largely concerned with matters extraneous to the text, e.g., with the biography or psychology of the author or the work's relationship to literary history.

Animal Minds. This article surveys philosophical issues related to the nature and scope of animal mentality, as well as to our commonsense understanding and scientific knowledge of animal minds. Intentionality should not be understood as the notion of " intending something ", but as the capacity to refer to possible situations of reality (Searle ).

Philosophy of language in the analytical tradition explored logic and accounts of the mind at the end of the nineteenth century, with English-speaking writers Frege and Russell being pivotal, followed by Wittgenstein (Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus), the Vienna Circle and the logical positivists, and Quine, while on the continent a foundation work was Ferdinand de Saussure's Cours de.

Perhaps no aspect of mind is more familiar or more puzzling than consciousness and our conscious experience of self and world.

The problem of consciousness is arguably the central issue in current theorizing about the mind.

Philosophy of language - Wikipedia